Likes
- All feature Subarus inherently safe and effective symmetrical all-wheel drive system.
- 6-cylinder variants offer a very appealing package.
- Signature Subaru feel and excellent build quality.
- Very appealing value for money across a huge range.
Firstly, addressing the nomenclature, it’s worth noting that while you might know this car as a Legacy, it goes by the name Liberty in Australia. This distinction is a sign of Subaru’s respect for an esteemed Australian organisation dedicated to caring for veterans and their families, known as Legacy.
If you happen to browse the classifieds in pursuit of a 4th Generation Liberty, seeking a diverse array of trim specifications, you’re in luck. Between 2003 and 2009, Subaru introduced no less than 22 different variants of this model locally.
Internationally, particularly in Japan, there were even more variations, not to mention the Outback which, while technically considered a distinct model, it’s essentially a raised and cladded version of the Liberty wagon.
Speaking of choices, even within the core options, you can opt for either the wagon or the sedan. Furthermore, there’s a selection of five different engines (details in the technical specs), with the option of automatic or manual transmissions. In 2006, a mid-cycle update refreshed the Liberty’s appearance.
Now, how can you spot an updated Liberty? Well, think of it as Subaru’s version of the cool cat-eye makeup trend – they gave the Liberty’s headlights a sleek makeover and of course, there were also updates in terms of technology, equipment, and mechanical improvements.
Across all the various versions and powertrain options, one constant feature stands out: every Liberty boasts Subaru’s signature symmetrical all-wheel-drive system and boxer engines.
Despite the attention and excitement surrounding models like the WRX and BRZ, many view the Liberty as Subaru’s unsung hero, underrated and under-appreciated, while, in particular, the 6-cylinder variants can be considered the underappreciated gems of this underestimated range.
While the turbocharged models often steal the spotlight, there’s a consensus among enthusiasts that it’s the 6-cylinder variants that hit the sweet spot in the range. What’s more, these 6-cylinder models tend to be far more budget-friendly when it’s time to make a purchase decision.
But in terms of that purchase decision, with this generation of Liberty now a couple decades old, should you buy one? Read on.
Exterior:
Specifically on the wagons, the paint on the plastic tailgate garnish and spoiler tends to deteriorate when exposed to the sun. It’s worth mentioning that when these components are removed for repainting, the panel can often break, adding to the repair complexity.
Another potential issue to be aware of across the range is the window motors, which have been known to fail. While it is possible to have them refurbished, it may be a more practical solution to replace them with new ones for improved reliability.
Additionally, problems can arise with the central locking and door lock actuators. While not a major expense to fix, these issues can be quite bothersome.
In the case of 6-speed manual models, there have been reports of reverse lights failing, with the switch being difficult to replace.
Depending on your geographical location, rust problems can emerge in various areas, including under the roof rails, beneath the scuff plates, and in front of the sill. This is something to watch out for, especially in regions with harsh weather conditions.
Another concern relates to the engine under tray, which uses soft bolts that are prone to snapping. After a few instances of this occurring, the under tray is often discarded, leaving the oil filter, exhaust manifold, and oil pan exposed.
Perhaps one of the most significant issues, especially in more performance-oriented models, is the potential for accident damage and subpar repairs. It is strongly recommended to watch our ultimate used car buyer’s guide for this model before considering a purchase, as it can potentially save you a significant amount of money.
Interior:
One significant concern involves the dashboard, which tends to develop cracks, peel, discolour, become shiny, and even exhibit signs of melting over time due to sun exposure and the natural aging process.
A common problem in many manual Subaru models from this era, including the Liberty, is the deterioration of shifter bushes. This can result in a loose or imprecise gear shifter. Another noteworthy quirk is the check engine light, which has a tendency to illuminate. Interestingly, some owners have found that ignoring it appears to work fine.
Issues can also arise with the HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) system, specifically related to the motors that control the airflow direction. These motors can fail or become stuck, making repairs a bit of a hassle.
The optional or upgraded McIntosh speakers in these cars have likely deteriorated over time and may not sound as good as they once did, necessitating replacement.
Furthermore, the coating on the door handles tends to wear off, leaving a sticky residue. Additionally, the clocks in these models can sometimes fail.
If the leather interiors haven’t been well-maintained,
Exterior:
Specifically on the wagons, the paint on the plastic tailgate garnish and spoiler tends to deteriorate when exposed to the sun. It’s worth mentioning that when these components are removed for repainting, the panel can often break, adding to the repair complexity.
Another potential issue to be aware of across the range is the window motors, which have been known to fail. While it is possible to have them refurbished, it may be a more practical solution to replace them with new ones for improved reliability.
Additionally, problems can arise with the central locking and door lock actuators. While not a major expense to fix, these issues can be quite bothersome.
In the case of 6-speed manual models, there have been reports of reverse lights failing, with the switch being difficult to replace.
Depending on your geographical location, rust problems can emerge in various areas, including under the roof rails, beneath the scuff plates, and in front of the sill. This is something to watch out for, especially in regions with harsh weather conditions.
Another concern relates to the engine under tray, which uses soft bolts that are prone to snapping. After a few instances of this occurring, the under tray is often discarded, leaving the oil filter, exhaust manifold, and oil pan exposed.
Perhaps one of the most significant issues, especially in more performance-oriented models, is the potential for accident damage and subpar repairs. It is strongly recommended to watch our ultimate used car buyer’s guide for this model before considering a purchase, as it can potentially save you a significant amount of money.
Interior:
One significant concern involves the dashboard, which tends to develop cracks, peel, discolour, become shiny, and even exhibit signs of melting over time due to sun exposure and the natural aging process.
A common problem in many manual Subaru models from this era, including the Liberty, is the deterioration of shifter bushes. This can result in a loose or imprecise gear shifter. Another noteworthy quirk is the check engine light, which has a tendency to illuminate. Interestingly, some owners have found that ignoring it appears to work fine.
Issues can also arise with the HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) system, specifically related to the motors that control the airflow direction. These motors can fail or become stuck, making repairs a bit of a hassle.
The optional or upgraded McIntosh speakers in these cars have likely deteriorated over time and may not sound as good as they once did, necessitating replacement.
Furthermore, the coating on the door handles tends to wear off, leaving a sticky residue. Additionally, the clocks in these models can sometimes fail.
If the leather interiors haven’t been well-maintained, the leather can become hardened and develop cracks. However, with proper care from the beginning, the leather should remain supple and attractive.
The steering wheel leather is another component that may show signs of wear and tear at this age. Similarly, the carpets often exhibit signs of aging over time. It’s essential for owners to be aware of these potential issues and consider proper maintenance and occasional replacements to keep their Liberty/Legacy in good condition.
Mechanically:
There’s a prevailing sentiment that the 4th generation Subaru Liberty/Legacy marked the end of an era for the model, and to some extent, we can understand why. Post this generation, Subaru’s once-sterling reputation for reliability has faced some challenges. However, it’s important to note that even within the 4th generation, there are certain issues worth considering.
The 4-cylinder models were equipped with versions of the EJ series engines. Notably, in Australia, there was no diesel option, which can be seen as an advantage since diesel engines can often bring their share of complications. Additionally, this generation boasts a conventional automatic transmission rather than a CVT, a choice that is advantageous considering the CVT’s well-documented reliability concerns.
Nonetheless, the EJ engine platform isn’t without its flaws. Many owners have reported head gasket leaks, often manifesting as external coolant and oil leaks, typically on the left-hand side. Oil leaks, particularly from the valve cover gaskets, can be problematic, dripping onto the exhaust and causing unpleasant odors. These leaks can also infiltrate the spark plug tubes, leading to ignition issues.
Furthermore, these models are known to encounter problems with oxygen sensors and catalytic converters. They tend to consume a significant amount of oil, necessitating regular checks and top-ups. An additional cost factor arises from the timing belt, which requires replacement every 100,000 kilometers, as do the Iridium spark plugs, making servicing relatively expensive.
In contrast, the 6-cylinder EZ30 engine offers slightly better reliability. However, it still has its share of issues, including oil leaks from valve covers, timing case gaskets, and oil cooler seals. This engine is also prone to oil consumption. While it doesn’t have a timing belt, making it somewhat lower maintenance, high-mileage or neglected examples may experience timing chain and tensioner issues, although this is not particularly common.
All models are susceptible to air conditioning compressor failures, as well as drive belt pulley and tensioner failures, which can result in shredded drive belts. In some extreme cases, this damage can extend to the timing belt cover, posing a risk to the timing belt itself.
Regarding the driveline, it generally performs adequately. Manual transmissions may suffer from the typical issue of floppy gear selectors due to worn bushes, a common problem in manual Subarus. They are also prone to leaking clutch hydraulics at this age. On the other hand, well-maintained automatic transmissions tend to be more reliable compared to the later CVT-equipped generations.
One crucial point to emphasise is the major timing belt service, required every 100,000 kilometres. It’s worth noting that many owners tend to sell their vehicles around the time when this service is due. Therefore, if you’re considering purchasing one, it’s imperative to inquire about the timing belt service history to ensure it has been properly addressed.
Exterior:
Specifically on the wagons, the paint on the plastic tailgate garnish and spoiler tends to deteriorate when exposed to the sun. It’s worth mentioning that when these components are removed for repainting, the panel can often break, adding to the repair complexity.
Another potential issue to be aware of across the range is the window motors, which have been known to fail. While it is possible to have them refurbished, it may be a more practical solution to replace them with new ones for improved reliability.
Additionally, problems can arise with the central locking and door lock actuators. While not a major expense to fix, these issues can be quite bothersome.
In the case of 6-speed manual models, there have been reports of reverse lights failing, with the switch being difficult to replace.
Depending on your geographical location, rust problems can emerge in various areas, including under the roof rails, beneath the scuff plates, and in front of the sill. This is something to watch out for, especially in regions with harsh weather conditions.
Another concern relates to the engine under tray, which uses soft bolts that are prone to snapping. After a few instances of this occurring, the under tray is often discarded, leaving the oil filter, exhaust manifold, and oil pan exposed.
Perhaps one of the most significant issues, especially in more performance-oriented models, is the potential for accident damage and subpar repairs. It is strongly recommended to watch our ultimate used car buyer’s guide for this model before considering a purchase, as it can potentially save you a significant amount of money.
Interior:
One significant concern involves the dashboard, which tends to develop cracks, peel, discolour, become shiny, and even exhibit signs of melting over time due to sun exposure and the natural aging process.
A common problem in many manual Subaru models from this era, including the Liberty, is the deterioration of shifter bushes. This can result in a loose or imprecise gear shifter. Another noteworthy quirk is the check engine light, which has a tendency to illuminate. Interestingly, some owners have found that ignoring it appears to work fine.
Issues can also arise with the HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) system, specifically related to the motors that control the airflow direction. These motors can fail or become stuck, making repairs a bit of a hassle.
The optional or upgraded McIntosh speakers in these cars have likely deteriorated over time and may not sound as good as they once did, necessitating replacement.
Furthermore, the coating on the door handles tends to wear off, leaving a sticky residue. Additionally, the clocks in these models can sometimes fail.
If the leather interiors haven’t been well-maintained, the leather can become hardened and develop cracks. However, with proper care from the beginning, the leather should remain supple and attractive.
The steering wheel leather is another component that may show signs of wear and tear at this age. Similarly, the carpets often exhibit signs of aging over time. It’s essential for owners to be aware of these potential issues and consider proper maintenance and occasional replacements to keep their Liberty/Legacy in good condition.
Mechanically:
There’s a prevailing sentiment that the 4th generation Subaru Liberty/Legacy marked the end of an era for the model, and to some extent, we can understand why. Post this generation, Subaru’s once-sterling reputation for reliability has faced some challenges. However, it’s important to note that even within the 4th generation, there are certain issues worth considering.
The 4-cylinder models were equipped with versions of the EJ series engines. Notably, in Australia, there was no diesel option, which can be seen as an advantage since diesel engines can often bring their share of complications. Additionally, this generation boasts a conventional automatic transmission rather than a CVT, a choice that is advantageous considering the CVT’s well-documented reliability concerns.
Nonetheless, the EJ engine platform isn’t without its flaws. Many owners have reported head gasket leaks, often manifesting as external coolant and oil leaks, typically on the left-hand side. Oil leaks, particularly from the valve cover gaskets, can be problematic, dripping onto the exhaust and causing unpleasant odors. These leaks can also infiltrate the spark plug tubes, leading to ignition issues.
Furthermore, these models are known to encounter problems with oxygen sensors and catalytic converters. They tend to consume a significant amount of oil, necessitating regular checks and top-ups. An additional cost factor arises from the timing belt, which requires replacement every 100,000 kilometers, as do the Iridium spark plugs, making servicing relatively expensive.
In contrast, the 6-cylinder EZ30 engine offers slightly better reliability. However, it still has its share of issues, including oil leaks from valve covers, timing case gaskets, and oil cooler seals. This engine is also prone to oil consumption. While it doesn’t have a timing belt, making it somewhat lower maintenance, high-mileage or neglected examples may experience timing chain and tensioner issues, although this is not particularly common.
All models are susceptible to air conditioning compressor failures, as well as drive belt pulley and tensioner failures, which can result in shredded drive belts. In some extreme cases, this damage can extend to the timing belt cover, posing a risk to the timing belt itself.
Regarding the driveline, it generally performs adequately. Manual transmissions may suffer from the typical issue of floppy gear selectors due to worn bushes, a common problem in manual Subarus. They are also prone to leaking clutch hydraulics at this age. On the other hand, well-maintained automatic transmissions tend to be more reliable compared to the later CVT-equipped generations.
One crucial point to emphasise is the major timing belt service, required every 100,000 kilometres. It’s worth noting that many owners tend to sell their vehicles around the time when this service is due. Therefore, if you’re considering purchasing one, it’s imperative to inquire about the timing belt service history to ensure it has been properly addressed.
Let us pose you a question: How passionate are you about cars?
If the idea of tinkering with your vehicle or dealing with frequent repairs doesn’t appeal to you, and your priority is practicality, reliability, and affordability, then consider purchasing a 4th generation Liberty or Legacy only if it meets the following criteria. It must have a low as possible mileage and preferably a limited number of previous owners, it must be in impeccable condition, and have a well-documented history of flawless servicing and maintenance. However, if these conditions aren’t met, you might want to consider the reliable but admittedly less exciting Toyota Camry, known for its longevity.
On the other hand, if you’re a true car enthusiast, someone who relishes both working on their vehicle as much as driving it, and you happen to come across an exceptional example, provided you have the passion, dedication, time, and financial resources required to maintain it properly, then by all means, go for it.
However, we would suggest considering a 6-cylinder and a manual transmission instead of a turbocharged four-cylinder. The 6-cylinder offers a unique and potentially more dependable driving experience while still delivering plenty of thrills.
Opting for the 6-cylinder might also help you steer clear of some of the common tuning and modification issues often associated with the turbo variants. Additionally, 6-cylinder models tend to be more budget-friendly, leaving you with extra funds to invest in high-quality, professionally installed modifications or necessary repairs.
Let us pose you a question: How passionate are you about cars?
If the idea of tinkering with your vehicle or dealing with frequent repairs doesn’t appeal to you, and your priority is practicality, reliability, and affordability, then consider purchasing a 4th generation Liberty or Legacy only if it meets the following criteria. It must have a low as possible mileage and preferably a limited number of previous owners, it must be in impeccable condition, and have a well-documented history of flawless servicing and maintenance. However, if these conditions aren’t met, you might want to consider the reliable but admittedly less exciting Toyota Camry, known for its longevity.
On the other hand, if you’re a true car enthusiast, someone who relishes both working on their vehicle as much as driving it, and you happen to come across an exceptional example, provided you have the passion, dedication, time, and financial resources required to maintain it properly, then by all means, go for it.
However, we would suggest considering a 6-cylinder and a manual transmission instead of a turbocharged four-cylinder. The 6-cylinder offers a unique and potentially more dependable driving experience while still delivering plenty of thrills.
Opting for the 6-cylinder might also help you steer clear of some of the common tuning and modification issues often associated with the turbo variants. Additionally, 6-cylinder models tend to be more budget-friendly, leaving you with extra funds to invest in high-quality, professionally installed modifications or necessary repairs.
Let us pose you a question: How passionate are you about cars?
If the idea of tinkering with your vehicle or dealing with frequent repairs doesn’t appeal to you, and your priority is practicality, reliability, and affordability, then consider purchasing a 4th generation Liberty or Legacy only if it meets the following criteria. It must have a low as possible mileage and preferably a limited number of previous owners, it must be in impeccable condition, and have a well-documented history of flawless servicing and maintenance. However, if these conditions aren’t met, you might want to consider the reliable but admittedly less exciting Toyota Camry, known for its longevity.
On the other hand, if you’re a true car enthusiast, someone who relishes both working on their vehicle as much as driving it, and you happen to come across an exceptional example, provided you have the passion, dedication, time, and financial resources required to maintain it properly, then by all means, go for it.
However, we would suggest considering a 6-cylinder and a manual transmission instead of a turbocharged four-cylinder. The 6-cylinder offers a unique and potentially more dependable driving experience while still delivering plenty of thrills.
Opting for the 6-cylinder might also help you steer clear of some of the common tuning and modification issues often associated with the turbo variants. Additionally, 6-cylinder models tend to be more budget-friendly, leaving you with extra funds to invest in high-quality, professionally installed modifications or necessary repairs.
Body Styles
Engine Specs
Transmission
Body Styles
Engine Specs
Transmission
Fuel Consumption
Length
Width
Height
Wheelbase
Kerb Weight
Towing
Ancap Ratings
Body Styles
Engine Specs
Transmission
Fuel Consumption
Length
Width
Height
Wheelbase
Kerb Weight
Towing
Ancap Ratings
Warranty
Servicing
Have ultimate peace of mind when buying a used car by purchasing an official PPSR report.
Please note that pricing information is subject to fluctuations in the automotive market.
Information correct as of Sep 22, 2023.
The advice provided on this website is general advice only. It has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on this advice, you should consider the appropriateness of the advice, having regard to your own objectives, financial situation and needs.
Read our full terms and conditions here.
You are the best, the content in your videos is so helpful, delivered in a great way. Please keep going as for sure you are unique in every way. All the best from Guatemala
L. G. - YouTube
You guys have truly found something wonderful… Loved this channel ever since from the beginning… Will support you guys as long as you guys keep making these wonderful car reviews…
Calvin - YouTube
This is probably the best channel I have ever seen when reviewing vehicles. New or old. The honesty is so appreciated. I’ve been a mechanic for 20 years and I find it very informative when looking for a vehicle for my daughter. Keep up the awesome work.
Jason T. - YouTube
© 2025 ReDriven All Rights Reserved